What is the modern creative director? – Part 4

Costs must be cut; every agency staffer knows this. But are cuts seriously damaging the quality of their creative output, costing agencies business down the road?

Costs must be cut; every agency staffer knows this. But are cuts seriously damaging the quality of their creative output, costing agencies business in the long term?

These are the issues addressed in the fourth part of Marketing‘s creative director roundtable, hosted by Ron Tite, vice-president of innovation practice at Euro RSCG.

Cutting costs isn’t just the edict from atop the multinationals. As Glen Hunt, former creative director at Dentsu Canada, points out, smaller independent shops are cutting to “the bone” as well, “and losing money because of it.”

Some shops are cutting down on billings to production and post-production companies, bringing such staff in-house. Israel Diaz, EVP and COO at Young & Rubicam Canada, believes this doesn’t result is good work.

“The work does start to suffer,” Diaz said. “You can always get better talent outside the walls, and they’re going to work with you anyway.” Producing high-quality work is the best long-term business practice, he said.

“Someone on the payroll is going to behave differently than someone you award a job to,” said David Houghton, CD at Two Headed. The incentive of awarding “the best person” for a job far outweighs the motivation of an in-house animator or producer who can get overwhelmed by all an agency’s projects.

However, Virginia Magaletta, ECD at Twist Image, said the situation is different at digital agencies, which have been hiring best-in-class production staff since their inception.

“We try to hire the experts, build the team and keep everything in-house,” because constant technological change requires a dedicated staffer watching things evolve “24-7. For us, it’s a blessing to keep bringing people in… It’s really hard to outsource and hire programmers and send the work out. You lose so much control and so much time.”

Houghton agreed with Magaletta, but said while digital agencies have been hiring experts, full-service agency production staff are usually hired to just “get it done.”

Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
Part 5

Advertising Articles

Interac brings back the stubborn Holiday Bill

New Zulu Alpha Kilo spots show Bill badgering people where they shop

BMO unveils first campaign from Y&R

A new, employee-built tagline is designed for Canadian and U.S. markets

Cossette sale could bring new international player to Canada

Chinese firm BlueFocus is eager to expand in North America

Supermarket chain battles criticism over World War I ad

Sainsbury's four-minute television spot depicts the 1914 Christmas Truce

Celebrating innovative Canadian charity marketing

Shortlisted entries in the charity and not-for-profit category of the 2014 MIAs

Alain Tadros elected to lead AAPQ board of directors

The Quebec-based industry association elects new board for 2014-15

Amnesty International takes Canadians for a trip

Campaign microsite takes a closer look at the human rights crisis in Mexico

Agency Wars V: Sonya Furdyk vs. Sabrina Hashmi

The industry's annual fundraiser is back

Marketing Hall of Legends reveals finalists for Marketer on the Rise award

Award identifies and celebrates the marketing leaders of tomorrow