What is the modern creative director – Part 5

Are creatives losing claim to being the most creative minds in business?

As Ron Tite points out, the ad industry did not fare well on Fast Company‘s last “Most Creative People In Business” list. Of the 100 names on the list, only two were from ad agencies (and only one Canadian made the list: HBC’s Bonnie Brooks.)

So his first question of the fifth and final part of our creative director round table is a fitting one: “Have we, as creatives, thought in the past that we owned that title of being the creative person in business? And are we losing that?”

“We want to be considered the most creative people, but everybody who considers themselves creative wants to be the most creative,” said Virginia Magaletta, ECD at Twist Image. “We make lists, and when we don’t get on the lists… when we don’t win the awards, it’s a really big problem. Nobody’s harder on themselves than creative directors.”

“The fact is everyone’s creative,” said Israel Diaz, CCO at Y&R Canada. “There’s just so much technology out there to express your creativity. We’re seeing creativity in every sector and industry. All of a sudden, we’re not the keepers, the gurus of creativity anymore… Sometimes you feel inadequate in this position because [some people] are saving the world and we’re just trying to get an ad out the door.”

Diaz and Magaletta were two of five creative directors who agreed to sit with Tite, vice-president of innovation practice at Euro RSCG, for a one-hour discussion on the ever growing challenges facing creatives in advertising. Joining them were Jon Freir, senior vice-president and creative director at MacLaren Momentum; David Houghton, CD at Two Headed; and and Glen Hunt, former CD at Dentsu Canada.

Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4

Advertising Articles

Dentsu Aegis acquires Spoke to bolster Isobar

Jeff Greenspoon and Kai Exos to lead merged agency

BCP and Publicis merge

Merger comes nearly two years after Yves Gougoux sells BCP to Publicis Worldwide

DS+P win Canadian agency of record status for Dulux

Agency will work with Headspace, which is tasked with strategy/creative for Quebec

Sid Lee gives a peek behind the curtain with Transform

Bi-monthly e-newsletter provides research-based industry insights and agency news

McDonald’s marketing misery

Markus Giesler on the chain's identity crisis and why it's becoming increasingly irrelevant

Toronto burger joint’s Allen Iverson parody a social hit

Restaurant owner talks about napkin shortage in low budget YouTube video

Toronto Star hires Rethink

Agency to focus on promoting the paper's print edition and tablet news products