Breaking Down The Sun Chips Bag Story

When is a chip bag too loud? Frito-Lay found out the answer earlier this month when it announced it would discontinue its line of biodegradable chip bags for fi ve of its Sun Chips brand’s six fl avours. Introduced in 2009, the bags boasted the ability to be fully composted in 14 weeks. It took […]

When is a chip bag too loud?

Frito-Lay found out the answer earlier this month when it announced it would discontinue its line of biodegradable chip bags for fi ve of its Sun Chips brand’s six fl avours. Introduced in 2009, the bags boasted the ability to be fully composted in 14 weeks. It took just over a year for the bags to be pulled due to consumer complaint.

A few e-mails might have had an impact, but probably not as much as the 11% decline in U.S. sales in the past year as reported in USA Today. It brings up an interesting question: For all the talk of more corporate environmental do-goodery, if consumers aren’t willing to take a little noise with their chips, why should marketers make the effort?

It’s a fi ne balance between making product changes to help the environment and changing the product so much it scares off the consumer. As superfi cial as it may seem, it’s no surprise that a noisy bag might scare off new Sun Chips fans . But that drop in sales must have come as a shock.

While tongue-in-cheek Facebook pages like “SORRY I CANT HEAR YOU OVER MY SUNCHIPS BAG” and tweets from Stephen Colbert (“The loud Sun Chips bag is dead! Long live the original Sun Chips bag! Which it will, since it’s not biodegradable!”) are funny, some lament what Frito-Lay’s decision says about consumer culture.

As Mother Jones’ writer Kate Sheppard said, “In the grand scheme of things, this is the absolute, bare-minimum level of sacrifi ce Americans are asked to make… If the sound of a crinkly eco-chip bag is too much to handle, then the human species really is screwed.”

It was also a pretty safe level of sacrifi ce for a major marketer. Biodegradable bags tie in perfectly with the Sun Chips brand, which was the best place for Frito-Lay to start experimenting with enviro-conscious packaging. I’m not saying they’re biodegradable dilettantes, but any serious discussion about environmentally friendly packaging should include the question, “What about the company’s other 20-odd bagged snack brands?”

In addition to fi nding a bag that can’t drown out the sound of a low-fl ying jumbo jet, hopefully the long-term goal is to establish an industry standard for all snack bags to be biodegradable, making it the rule rather than the exception. Then chipeaters unable to make the mental leap to pour chips into a bowl wouldn’t have a choice in the matter.

Brands Articles

Your Marketing newsletters are changing

The Marketing Morning Filter is ending, but other newsletters are set to return

The List: North Strategic’s very big year

Prior to being picked up by MSLGroup, the PR shop brought in 15 new client wins

The biggest stories in Canadian marketing: 2016

A look back at the most read and shared news items from MarketingMag.ca

Media Profile teams with global PR group

PRGN welcomes Toronto agency as first Canadian partner

Stereo+ unveils brand overhaul from Lg2boutique

How to to introduce a 35-year-old chain to younger shoppers

The List: Wattpad’s evolving influence

The first of our selections for the biggest newsmakers of 2016

Sears Canada takes a gamble on groceries

Losses more than double in Q3 report, but food markets set to arrive

Big opportunities await in the new age of CSR (column)

Overwhelmed consumers want to outsource their consciences, but it requires deep trust

Mintel predicts packaging trends for 2017

Research firm says intelligent, experiential packaging will lead consumer experiences